67 Grosvenor St | Mayfair | London W1K 3JN | T: 020 7769 6831

Defining “Moneyboxing” in the Context of Company Liquidation, and How HMRC is Intending to Clamp Down


Defining “Moneyboxing” in the Context of Company Liquidation, and How HMRC is Intending to Clamp Down

What is “moneyboxing”?


“Moneyboxing” in business refers to a strategic financial manoeuvre whereby a company accumulates profits well beyond what is necessary for its operational needs. This surplus is deliberately retained within the company’s books with the primary aim of securing a tax advantage upon the company’s closure, or other specific financial events.

At its core, moneyboxing involves the deliberate accumulation and retention of profits within a business entity. This practice is often employed to optimise tax benefits, exploiting legal loopholes or favourable tax regulations in anticipation of future closure, restructuring, or dissolution of the company.

The motivation behind moneyboxing typically revolves around tax optimisation. By retaining excessive profits within the company rather than distributing them through dividends or reinvesting them in the business, entities seek to minimise their tax liabilities. This surplus of retained earnings might not be aligned with the company’s immediate operational requirements or growth strategies but serves as a financial cushion or strategic asset for future tax planning.

Moneyboxing can take various forms within a company’s financial management:

  1. Tax Deferral Strategy: The company deliberately holds onto profits without distributing them to shareholders or investing them in business expansion. This action delays the tax obligation, allowing the company to benefit from the time value of money.
  2. Capital Gains Optimisation: In cases where the company anticipates closure, restructuring, or acquisition, holding excess profits can strategically position the business to benefit from more favourable tax treatments on capital gains.
  3. Avoiding Higher Tax Brackets: Companies might strategically withhold profits to avoid moving into higher tax brackets.


What are the risks?


However, while moneyboxing might seem financially advantageous, it can draw scrutiny from tax authorities and regulatory bodies. Authorities often monitor such practices to prevent abuse or exploitation of tax laws. HMRC has expressed concern about companies employing this practice, viewing it as “aggressive” tax planning and unfair to other tax payers who are unable make the same arrangements. Subsequently, directors looking to close down a company via a Members’ Voluntary Liquidation (MVL) will likely find that HMRC will apply much scrutiny when assessing the reasons for closure, attempting to identify any instances where moneyboxing may have taken place.

Moreover, moneyboxing might not always align with good corporate governance or shareholder interests. Hoarding excessive profits instead of deploying them for growth, dividends, or reinvestment can hinder a company’s innovation, expansion, or shareholder returns, potentially leading to discontent among stakeholders.

In conclusion, moneyboxing represents a financial strategy aimed at optimising tax benefits by accumulating surplus profits within a company beyond its operational needs. While it can offer short-term tax advantages, it also poses risks in terms of regulatory compliance and long-term strategic growth. HMRC is increasingly looking for ways to clamp down on such practices, and company directors should be weary of this.

For further information or advice, contact the business recovery experts at Voscap today on 020 7769 6831, or email help@voscap.co.uk.

About Voscap Ltd

Voscap’s primary objective is to save your business! Our team of experts’ knowledge in restructuring and turnaround assignments is invaluable when assessing the best option available to your needs. With experience spanning several decades, we have the skill and resources to provide viable solutions within all industry sectors. All organisations go through difficult times and we are here to help. From small to multi-million turnover businesses, we have dealt with the most complex of cases. We offer an initial free assessment in analysing your financial position and providing clear and precise advice making your experience a simple non-complicated process. Get in touch →